If you caught last week’s episode of The Lost Cookbooks Show, you know we tackled the winning viewer poll recipe from the 1946 edition of The Joy of Cooking: Hot Emergency Sandwiches. Between the canned biscuits and the canned deviled ham, it was certainly a nostalgic trip back to mid-century convenience cooking—and it was also a serious hit of sodium and carbs!
I have been sticking strictly to a low-carb routine all week just to recover from that meal. With Thanksgiving right around the corner, I’m hoping to drop a couple of pounds before the holiday feast arrives, so my body definitely needed a break from canned biscuit dough.
Thankfully, as we continue our deep dive into the massive Luncheon and Supper Dishes chapter of this 1946 classic, we are moving into territory that feels a whole lot more like real home cooking. For Episode 21, we are exploring the sections dedicated to Meat Pies and creative ways to use up leftovers in all kinds of hearty dishes.
(And yes, if you’ve seen the thickness of this book, you know we still have plenty of pages left in Luncheon and Supper Dishes—we are going to be camping out in this chapter for quite a while!)

A Look Inside the 1946 Leftover & Meat Pie Playbook
In the mid-1940s, right on the heels of wartime rationing, wasting food in the kitchen simply wasn’t an option. Irma Rombauer dedicated entire subsections to transforming yesterday’s roast beef, baked ham, or Sunday chicken into a completely fresh, comforting supper.
As I flip through these pages to pick out four contenders for this week’s YouTube poll, I’m looking at:
- Classic Meat Pies: From savory beef and vegetable fillings topped with flaky pastry crusts to shepherd’s-style pies crowned with fluffy mashed potatoes or biscuit toppings.
- Leftover Transformations: Creative casseroles, hashes, croquettes, and baked loaf recipes designed to stretch a small amount of cooked meat into a full family meal.
- Smart Seasonings & Gravies: Using pan drippings, herbs, and rich sauces to keep reheated meats tender and flavorful without relying on heavily processed shortcuts.
One Strict Rule for This Week’s Poll
After last week’s sodium overload, I am putting my foot down on one thing while narrowing down our four options: no canned meats! You will not see any recipes calling for deviled ham, Vienna sausages, or potted meat on the ballot this time around. We are sticking to fresh ingredients and real leftovers for Episode 21.
Cast Your Vote on YouTube!
Once I finalize the four recipes from the Meat Pies and Leftovers sections, the poll will go live right over on the Bobbi Jo’s YouTube channel Community tab. Head over there to check out the contenders and vote for the vintage dish you want to see me cook and taste-test (with Steve, of course!) in Episode 21.
Which type of vintage comfort food are you hoping makes the final four—a traditional crusted meat pie, a mashed-potato-topped casserole, or an old-fashioned leftover hash? Let me know in the comments below, and don’t forget to vote on YouTube!


Leave a Reply